Posts Tagged ‘Comcast’

Question Asked: Is Tivo Really Worth It?

Having previously named Tivo as the greatest invention of the 20th century, personally, I’d say yes.

Many people think that Tivo’s just a way to digitally record TV shows, like a new-age VCR.  While that’s true, that’s only part of what Tivo does for you.

Tivo changes the way you watch television, and you’ll never be able to survive without it.  My wife and I have two Tivo s, and have been faithful subscribers for around four or five years now.

People may claim to have a “Tivo “, when in reality they’re referring to a DVR from either DirecTV or Comcast.  This is not a Tivo, by any means.  When my wife and I got our first HD television, we made the mistake of getting a Comcast HD DVR.  After having Tivo for three years, the Comcast DVR just wasn’t the same. It wasn’t nearly as good, or featureful.  I disconnected the Comcast HD DVR after four days, and returned it to Comcast that weekend.  When asked why I was returning it, I cited “It’s not a Tivo .”

A few months later, we purchased the Tivo HD Series 3, and haven’t looked back yet.  Not only is the Series 3 Tivo the only THX certified DVR on the planet, but in conjunction with the wireless adapter you can transfer HD shows to your computer, and never run out of space (assuming you’ve got space on your computer, of course.)  Can you do that with a Comcast DVR? No.

Not only will Tivo let you record shows when you tell it to, but it’ll also automatically record shows for you if you’ve set a season pass, and the time/day has changed.  I don’t know about you, but I very rarely go and check TV Guide to see if my favorite show’s been moved.  With Tivo , you don’t have to.  It just knows.

Hate commercials? Who doesn’t.  Got a Tivo ? Problem solved.  If you’re watching a live show, simply pause the Tivo for 15 minutes at the start of your one hour program (or 6 and a half minutes for your half hour show.)  Then you’ll be able to zip through commercials throughout the entire program, and it’ll end “on time”, so you can move onto the next show.  Once you’ve had a Tivo for a while, you’ll be able to perfect this commercial skipping.  That alone is worth the monthly fee.

I’ll admit, I was skeptical at first.  I had gotten an old Sony Tivo (the original series) years and years ago, as a promotion from a company that I worked for.  I wasn’t sold on the idea, so I sold the Tivo on eBay.

Years later, when visiting some of my wife’s family down in New York City, I experienced Tivo first hand, as they had one in their home.  Upon returning home, I ordered one that night.  Once you’ve tried it, you need to have it.  It’s a life changing experience.

I’ve been asked if Tivo is “worth it”, and I answer a resounding “yes.”  While people may not like that they’ve got to pay a fee to use the service, and argue that they can get the box from the “cable company” for less, what they don’t realize is, that it’s not that much less on a monthly basis.

Let’s assume you get the standard Tivo , single tuner, non HD.  Tivo generally gives these away with a service subscription of one or two years.  A two year contract will cost you roughly $12.95 a month.  If you were to get the box from Comcast, for example, your costs would be $50 to have them come out and install it for you, and then roughly $7.95 per month, plus taxes.

That’s $145.40 for the first year of service, compared to Tivo ’s $155.40.  Is Tivo worth $10 more per year? Yes.  The service is far superior to any DVR on the market, despite what you hear on the DirecTV commercial.

Seeing really is believing though, if you have an inkling to get a Tivo, but aren’t 100% sure, go try one.  Surely someone you know owns one.  If not, most Best Buy stores have a working demo of the HD version in their stores.

If you’re considering going with the one from Comcast or DirecTV, just because it’s “easier”, think twice.  If you look up reviews of those boxes from people who own them, you’ll find that the majority of them are negative reviews.  While Tivo, on the other hand, are glowingly positive in most cases.

If you’re in the Boston area, I’ll gladly demo my HD (and non-HD) Tivo setup for you. As long as you promise not to rob me.

Question Asked: What is the Greatest Invention of the 20th Century?

Another entirely subjective question, thanks for asking CJ.

My answer would be Tivo, however, that’s not the “real” answer, despite the fact that many people would agree.

The “greatest invention” of the 20th century according to the first four results pages of a Google search, would be either electricity, or the automobile. Many lesser trusted resources (namely Yahoo! answers, and Wikipedia) would say things such as; computers, mobile phones, and television.

However, upon further examination, neither electricity or the automobile were invented in the 20th century. Let’s examine:

Electricity wasn’t invented, ever. It was discovered. Electricity is produced naturally on earth, and is not a man made invention. Therefore, it doesn’t qualify. Oh, and the first known instance of electricity happened as early 600BC, when Thales of Miletus wrote about how rubbing amber created an attraction. This is known today, as static electricity. The word “electric” was first used in 1600 by Richard Gilbert, a British scientist. “Electricity” comes from the Greek word for “amber”. Fitting, eh? It wasn’t until 1752 when Benjamin Franklin flew his famous kite, and since that date, people have always assumed that he discovered electricity. False.

The automotive is also a touchy subject. The first steam powered motorized carriage was built in 1769, in France, by Nicolas Cugnot. The first electrically driven car was built by Robert Anderson in the 1830s, in Scotland. The first gasoline powered automobile was built in 1885 by Gottlieb Daimler (as in Daimler Chrysler, those people still making cars today). Also in 1885, Karl Benz built the first combustion engine powered automobile (just like what we drive today, sort of). Karl Benz, yes, like Mercedes Benz.

So, for the first time ever, Google is wrong. Four pages worth of wrong.

I guess, then, I stick to my original answer: Tivo. Those that don’t have one wouldn’t understand. Oh, and a Comcast or DirecTV DVR is not a Tivo, don’t fool yourself.



Ask MJ Your Question

Submit your question to Ask MJ and MJ will answer your question on the site, and email you to let you know it has been answered.